We are looking for India's Top 50 HROs. Submit your application today. Enter Now!

Latest Articles

 Five reasons to create a compelling Personal Brand

Five reasons to create a compelling Personal Brand...

calender Mar 31, 2021

We are all well aware of the appraisal calibrations where a decision to promote a person is based on...

 Three Things to do Before You Begin Your Personal Branding Journey

Three Things to do Before You Begin Your Personal ...

calender Mar 31, 2021

Building a compelling personal brand is not just good for you but it’s great for business, for...

 Deepika Padukone and How to Position Yourself

Deepika Padukone and How to Position Yourself...

calender Mar 25, 2021

Amongst the raft of celebrities that are showing their love of ripped jeans, Deepika is a notable ab...

 What colour is your collar?

What colour is your collar?...

calender Mar 24, 2021

For as long as we can remember, we had workers classified broadly into “white collar” or...

Latest Trending Articles

 Leadership Insights: Priyanka Anand, Vice President and Head of Human Resources, Ericsson India Global Services

Leadership Insights: Priyanka Anand, Vice Presiden...

calender Jan 10, 2018

  Leaders play a key role in shaping the future of any organization especially w.r.t. their hu...

A Hell of a Bell to manage

 A Hell of a Bell to manage


Life is full of tests and contests.. We had to do well in exams when we were young, had to score well in the Entrance Tests to get into a good BSchool and as we get older will have to do well in our Medical Tests. Amidst all this, Appraisals are yet another test…. a report card of the year gone by. A test that will decide if you can buy that car, afford a house or go for a long holiday this year. The stakes are high as the one thing our country has gained over the past few decades is competitiveness. And most of the times it’s not about what you got, but it’s about what the others got.


So this blog post is for all HR professionals who will be busy during this time of the year. Busy as we not only have to deal with several spreadsheets, documents and an elaborate appraisal process (that is hopefully online), but mostly cause we have to deal with several aroused emotions of ego, disappointment and anger. A lot of these directed to the HR function. 


One of the other tough parts about the Appraisal process is that on one side we have fairness & consistency in mind and on the other side there is business and practical issues to take care of. And I believe that a good HR professional has to balance both. It’s very easy to have a well-structured model that is based on market data and bell curve and compa ratios, but it’s very tough to know where to draw the lines.


The tragedy of creating a fair Reward system is the need to deal with fewer variables. Few variables mean we need to categorize people in buckets or Ranks or Ratings. This allows us to then build several models that we think are the most fair. Not just that, in order to ensure evaluations are consistent, we force rank people into the BELL CURVE.


So my question to all HR professionals is that does it really work?

If we do not expect our employees to compare each other’s salary and bonuses, why do we propagate a relative Rating mechanism that compares their performances?

Is trying to be fair the most unfair practice?

Can we deal with the Rewards exercise without really putting a number on each employee?

Can we do this differently?


I don’t have an answer to that question. And even some organisations that claim to have eliminated Ratings, actually haven't. They have just camouflaged it to a certain extent. Would most definitely want to hear from others who have attempted to answer this question. But I do know that the ‘how part’ is as important as the ‘What part’.


Following are some of my learnings around managing the process: 

  • Firstly, do not take to heart the nasty blaming comments. It’s what the doctors need to endure when they have to give the bad news
  • Make sure that you try as hard as possible to create an environment where development of the employee remains core to the appraisal system
  • You will have to make exceptions to your process. Just let them be few and let them be the right ones
  • Your reward strategy cannot be kept a well-guarded secret. Talk to your stakeholders about the rationale. Either you are transparent or you are unfair.
  • Take some effort in creating a good perception about the process. A little marketing helps. Everyone likes an attractive package (No I didn’t mean salary package).
  • One emotion that either gets over played or forgotten is ‘Empathy’. Don’t get completely carried away by emotions. However, without empathy you will be like the 90s multistarrer movie. They had everything except an audience.


Lastly, keep your ego at bay. When the going gets tough, don’t swell and don’t sulk. Write a blog instead :-)


The views expressed here are personal of the author and not representative of the organization in any way. 


Profile:Hamsaz Vasunia is Head HR & Training at DCB Bank. 


Published with permission.